Okay, I made these cookies last night…and again tonight. They are that good. (Just to be clear, I took the cookies I made last night to book club, so it’s not like we ate 3 dozen cookies in one night…just 1 dozen is all. But I can’t promise we won’t eat 3 dozen tonight!)
I found the recipe on this blog. She found the recipe on this blog. That blogger found the recipe in a cookbook. So, I can’t lay any claim whatsoever to discovering this little gem, but I’m sure glad I stumbled upon it! (Thanks to Ashley at Delish for commenting here on TWFD, otherwise I might never have been introduced to my new love…the Chocolate Chip Amish Puff Cookie.)
I rolled the cookies in cinnamon sugar as is suggested and it was, well, DELISH!
Enjoy!
Hi! My name is Jane Maynard and you've landed yourself on my blog, This Week for Dinner™. Every Sunday I share a weekly menu...and count on you to share yours! You'll also find other deliciousness that I hope you'll enjoy!
Thank you for the link, Jane! It’s good to know that my accidental addition of cinnamon and sugar to the Amish Puff Cookie recipe is going over so well 😉 Excellent image of the cookies!
I think maybe we will try these today. It’s rainy here and the perfect day to make cookies together!
you’re welcome, erin! thanks for the great cinnamon sugar idea! it really is a great addition to the recipe.
anna – you’ll love them, perfect for a rainy day. although…you’ll be stuck at home with an abundance of delicious cookies. don’t blame me if you eat them all! 🙂
I made these cookies last night and they were delicious!! They taste just like snickerdoodle cookies!
Jane! these cookies are amazing. We ate every single one!
thank you!!
I made these too and they are FABULOUS!!! I love them!